Comments about all grids

DH @ #18840: Great (38 minutes ago)

edwardo @ #18913: The "Cholera" group would make more sense in a sequences round but otherwise I liked the grid - hard to find the groups (except the "Cholera" one which was easy) but all totally sensible when you see them. You're one of my favourite setters on the site! (1 hour, 27 minutes ago)

edwardo @ #18917: I think the "Martin" and "Liverpool" groups are rather poor and unimaginative, the former particularly because usually the link needs to be tighter than that, i.e. they all contain something that's the same in meaning, like "hidden alcoholic drinks" as on a recent OC show. (2 hours, 25 minutes ago)

Paul @ #12418: Answered City came up wrong then gave correct answer as City (2 hours, 46 minutes ago)

Paul @ #16893: Good wall never heard of the places in Illinois (2 hours, 54 minutes ago)

Paul @ #18927: Good wall once I got my head around it. Disappointed didn’t get the movements link. Good work (2 hours, 57 minutes ago)

Paul @ #18839: Good wall. Some very obscure links and a few red herrings (3 hours, 3 minutes ago)

OSSIEP9 @ #18923: Fair comment BinDipper........may be best for you to skip my latest one then!!..8-) (4 hours, 1 minute ago)

Jon @ #1708: Saw this rated as hard but they were all fiendish to me (5 hours, 5 minutes ago)

Jon @ #11953: I put in "rhyming words" for the Crime group but it didn't allow it as a correct entry. (5 hours, 21 minutes ago)

Jon @ #14418: This was in the USA category and "colors" was not allowed to be correct. Not very good. Colours and Colors should be allowed. Also, "woodwinds" wasn't allowed for the instruments which seems weird. (5 hours, 24 minutes ago)

wev @ #17952: Top grid (5 hours, 28 minutes ago)

wev @ #17954: fun grid but we can't always guess precisely what wording is in your mind - the answer categories need to be a bit broader. (5 hours, 31 minutes ago)

Jon @ #45: Timbres group wouldn't accept "music terms" as a correct answer. (5 hours, 32 minutes ago)

Dan @ #1942: Far too easy but a lot of fun (5 hours, 34 minutes ago)

Dan @ #98: Very good! (5 hours, 37 minutes ago)

Daisy @ #18923: Enjoyed this one (5 hours, 53 minutes ago)

Daisy @ #18923: (5 hours, 54 minutes ago)

Chris @ #5444: Speling not grate. (6 hours, 23 minutes ago)

BinDipper @ #18923: Enjoyable grid OS. If there’s any criticism it would just be that grids tend to be more fun when there’s variety in the way the links are made imo. Cheers. (6 hours, 28 minutes ago)

Chris @ #18888: Which Tarantino movie has the word killing in its title? (7 hours, 8 minutes ago)

Chris @ #18915: Chris' will do nicely.. (7 hours, 14 minutes ago)

OSSIEP9 @ #16199: Split a ticket???????? But a nice grid all the same (7 hours, 23 minutes ago)

Dan @ #3188: Too easy (8 hours, 17 minutes ago)

wev @ #17962: Top class deflection. (8 hours, 22 minutes ago)

wev @ #17964: Men's names too broad. If I hadn't been looking for something more specialised I could have scored 10/10! (8 hours, 39 minutes ago)

wev @ #17967: Maybe include 'quartet' in the fours answer. (8 hours, 47 minutes ago)

Iggy Swan @ #18920: After someone pointed to me that there was an error, I have amended wall 18868 slightly. (8 hours, 57 minutes ago)

Dan @ #6833: Good quiz and fun! (9 hours, 3 minutes ago)

NJ @ #231: Fabulous! (9 hours, 3 minutes ago)

Iggy Swan @ #18868: Yes Andyroo is right. (9 hours, 6 minutes ago)

Anna cotta @ #18526: What is the link?Pony, not accepted. (9 hours, 6 minutes ago)

Pip @ #18325: Ne-ni-ne-ni-neh! (9 hours, 16 minutes ago)

Verr @ #337: Nice! 😵 (9 hours, 19 minutes ago)

Andyroo @ #18868: Harry Kane went in goals in a European game, not the Premier League (9 hours, 30 minutes ago)

Dan @ #186: Quality but on the easy side (9 hours, 53 minutes ago)

BinDipper @ #18915: Yep, thanks AK. I suspected there might be an issue. King is now Danielle Rowe, Alarch. She was King in 2012. There were only meant to be 7 with the same occupation. Martin and Evans sneaked up on me. (10 hours, 22 minutes ago)

Dan @ #8403: War-saw. Er no! Poor. (11 hours, 13 minutes ago)

Dan @ #184: Aren’t these made by Pixar (11 hours, 23 minutes ago)

Anna cotta @ #18902: What’s the link? Pie, wouldn’t accept. (11 hours, 26 minutes ago)

Ka @ #18813: Good grid- enjoyed the crossovers (13 hours, 9 minutes ago)

sd @ #18867: Wouldn't accept David. (13 hours, 15 minutes ago)

Alarch, J @ #18917: I am happy that I've found this wall - it has Laity in it. That group was hard to spot the connection. (13 hours, 19 minutes ago)

Alarch, J @ #18918: Fairly simple to spot, may be one example of a wall asked in the earlier rounds of the show (13 hours, 25 minutes ago)

Alarch, J @ #18915: Nine entries with the same occupation though I could not find who King is in this category. (13 hours, 28 minutes ago)

asdcole @ #18544: Great music! Never heard of adult orientated rock (14 hours, 34 minutes ago)

Ak @ #18915: Martin, Evans, Froome and Boardman are also well known cyclists. (14 hours, 45 minutes ago)

Ak @ #18821: Great! (15 hours, 5 minutes ago)

anthony @ #18916: bugs speltl wrong bee , crawl otherwise a good grid (16 hours, 10 minutes ago)

anthony @ #18916: bugs speltl wrong bee , crawl otherwise a good grid (16 hours, 10 minutes ago)

BinDipper @ #18914: They've no excuse. Number 9 was there at the time. (16 hours, 40 minutes ago)

Iggy Swan @ #18873: A grid full of famous people from different areas of occupations. Joe Sugg, James Carter and Jim Morrisson I am not familiar with however. (16 hours, 46 minutes ago)

baz @ #18897: good (17 hours, 9 minutes ago)

baz @ #18897: good (17 hours, 10 minutes ago)

baz @ #18900: too many first names (17 hours, 15 minutes ago)

Tbone @ #18914: A couple of good red herrings. I feel like specific knowledge is required for two of these groups, and I'm not sure how much those fanbases cross over (17 hours, 17 minutes ago)

Tbone @ #18913: The links all made sense, but I couldn't find the groups to begin with. (17 hours, 19 minutes ago)

baz @ #18902: ok (17 hours, 20 minutes ago)

Tbone @ #18902: What on Earth is the group with K and 2? I understand what the link means, but some form words, some form symbols. It makes very little sense and wouldn't easily be guessed. The rest of the grid was a walk in the park. (17 hours, 24 minutes ago)

Tbone @ #18916: The main difficulty was spelling errors, then I struggled writing the links you were looking for. Didn't accept food or insects. Only noticed one red herring so very easy to group them. (17 hours, 27 minutes ago)

baz @ #18902: why not pie? (18 hours, 8 minutes ago)

baz @ #18915: good (18 hours, 19 minutes ago)

BinDipper @ #18916: It will outscore my grids, and deservedly so. (18 hours, 54 minutes ago)

Timmon @ #18916: Sorry. Not that good. Imo It's Crawl not crall. Butterfly is one word, likewise Backstroke. Sculling (as it should be spelt) is not a swimming stoke. And it's a Bee. (18 hours, 58 minutes ago)

H @ #18916: Thanks, i learnt about the swimming stroke sculling. (19 hours, 11 minutes ago)

gbshok @ #10172: For the "Northern" group, "Southern" works as well! (19 hours, 25 minutes ago)

Kat B @ #18916: Loved it. (19 hours, 34 minutes ago)

Verr @ #311: I feel that the list of supposed terms for animal groups is not a good connection. It is not a real thing, they are not used (apart from a small number of real ones) those weird ones are just a trope propagated as a curiosity. (19 hours, 43 minutes ago)

cazza @ #14369: got the connections very quickly but every single one of my answers was rejected even although I said the correct connection. very very and another very poor breadth of acceptable answers (19 hours, 45 minutes ago)

cazza @ #14372: people of Britain rejected as the answer was british people - haha (19 hours, 52 minutes ago)

Verr @ #307: Enjoyed that one (19 hours, 55 minutes ago)

Verr @ #306: Nice one, thanks. (20 hours, 5 minutes ago)

PK @ #18849: enjoyed the confusion :) (20 hours, 24 minutes ago)

PK @ #18840: keep them coming! (20 hours, 27 minutes ago)

BinDipper @ #18868: I think that happens if you’ve included punctuation that the software doesn’t like, Mike. Or you have the settings on which grids to show wrong. You can adjust for difficulty and (alleged) quality. (20 hours, 28 minutes ago)

BinDipper @ #18915: Bit worried that the solution here might not be unique without Ms Coren-Mitchell cracking the whip but fingers crossed it is. (20 hours, 31 minutes ago)

PK @ #18821: another fun one :) (20 hours, 31 minutes ago)

PK @ #18815: fun fun fun (20 hours, 35 minutes ago)

Jeannie @ #18897: Enjoyed this, good crossovers! (20 hours, 41 minutes ago)

Jeannie @ #18902: No crossovers, and won't accept pie as answer. Should be in easy group, not medium (20 hours, 45 minutes ago)

BinDipper @ #18902: Aye, a slip up on the pie front. My guess is the setter either put pies in the keyword section or just forgot completely. (22 hours, 11 minutes ago)

lindy @ #18897: 10/10 so I enjoyed it. (22 hours, 54 minutes ago)

lindy @ #18902: Why was "pie" not accepted? (22 hours, 56 minutes ago)

wev @ #17973: good but frustrating that "- castle" wasn't accepted while "castle -" was. (1 day ago)

wev @ #17986: Pretty easy, but surely "same letters" should be allowable in a category where all the words have the same letters. (1 day, 1 hour ago)

wev @ #17988: Excellent grid - just what the game should be about. (1 day, 1 hour ago)

wev @ #18000: You need to add more synonyms to the blue line. A very basic one was not accepted, and I'm 'unhappy' about that. (1 day, 3 hours ago)

Omegaman @ #18814: Good work. (1 day, 3 hours ago)

Omegaman @ #18813: Great grid thanks. (1 day, 3 hours ago)

X @ #18815: Great fun (1 day, 5 hours ago)

PP @ #18816: Really enjoy these (1 day, 5 hours ago)

PP @ #18902: didn't accept "pie" for the "banoffee" group (1 day, 6 hours ago)

Clodius @ #7374: Also, Jellystone isn't a real park; it's from the 60s cartoon Yogi Bear (1 day, 6 hours ago)

wev @ #18033: Really enjoyed this one - got there with 2 seconds to spare. (1 day, 6 hours ago)

RBR45 @ #18890: won't accept "warrior" or bands formed from breakup of band - otherwise would have got 10/10. (1 day, 6 hours ago)

wev @ #18034: 'half Scottish bands' not accepted, which was disappointing (1 day, 6 hours ago)

Me @ #18890: Rubbish (1 day, 6 hours ago)

wev @ #18035: 'tube stations' not accepted - no other city in the world calls their underground the tube. (1 day, 6 hours ago)

wev @ #18039: good stuff! (1 day, 6 hours ago)

Jime @ #10740: Very good quiz (1 day, 6 hours ago)

By default only the most recent 100 comments are displayed. Display all.